Throw light on the various mechanisms for the settlement of disputes related to the equitable sharing of river water among states. Also, evaluate the effectiveness of these mechanisms in the resolution of inter-state river water disputes in the country.
Zinnia Aurora, AIR 6, 2025
Inter state river water disputes, as delved into under Article 262, provide for ambit of mechanisms for effective resolution of same.
Disputes Kaveri, Pennar, Ghagra, Godavari, Krishna
[diagram: a funnel narrowing downward with Mahanadi, Godavari, Krishna, Kaveri, Pennar converging into it]
Mechanisms suggested include 1. Inter-State River water dispute Tribunal - constitutionally set up - set up separately for different disputes. - outside jurisdiction of SC judicial review. 2. River Boards Act - River Boards set up for administering arrangements - Central representation in maintenance of dams and rivers of interstate candour. 3. Not under jurisdiction of Supreme court, but only tribunal. 4. Arbitration and Negotiation, under Union's eye for effective dispute resolution 5. Treaty-based distribution of riverine assets among states
Effectiveness 1. Long gestation of disputes due to lack of cooperation between states - (eg) Mettur Dam dispute. 2. Tribunal's decisions taken to SC to effect SLP etc to seek appeals -> lack of decisive end to dispute. 3. River based state-boundary disputes coagulate with this issue. 4. River Boards effectiveness in question due to federal disbalance. 5. Rising demand within state for energy, water causing increased daming and changing status of rights of lower riparian states.
While Constitution provides mechanisms for amicable dispute settlement, a need is seen to effect more cohesive mechanisms touching newer demands.