Topper Copies

"There is no greater inequality than the equal treatment of unequals." In light of the statement examine the affirmative action policy of the Indian State with respect to reservations. (15 marks)

Vikas, AIR 27, 2025

Michael Walzer in his book Spheres of Justice held that Equality is a "complex" issue.

Similarly Aristotle in his theory of equality believed that treating unequals equally is injustice.

John Rawls in his theory of justice provided for "difference" principle for achieving "democratic equality".

Based on vision of social liberal scholars like John Rawls concept of affirmative action based on positive liberty evolved. It aims to provide an equitable distribution of resources instead of equal distribution to care for the disadvantaged sections so that they are not forced to live beyond their human dignity. [Kant's categorical imperative].

Equal treatment of unequals can lead to injustice because disadvantaged sections like Dalits in India, Minorities, SC's, ST's and women lack capacity and it can create a divide of rich and poor. It is more favourable to advantaged sections in society.

Affirmative action by India in the form of Reservations were emphasised by Dr. B.R Ambedkar as "compensatory justice" to create a level playing field in the society. Extension of reservations to OBC's under Mandal commission and to EWS by 103rd constitutional amendment aims to achieve an equal society.

Similarly, on lines of "Differentiated citizenship by Dr B R Ambedkar, reservations were extended to women by 73rd and 74th Amendment. Recently, Nari Shakti Vandan Adhiniyam extended them to Parliament and state legislatures too.

James Petty advocated reservations for their positive impact on upliftment of Dalits. B.S. [?] called reservation to women as a "silent revolution" and a crucial part of "Panchayat to Parliament" upon.

However phenomena of "elite capture" [Andre Beteille] considers reservation and it requires constant updations to remove inefficiencies in reservation system as per Andre Beteille.

Scholars like Arvind Panagariya denounce reservation for their merit impact. Recent verdicts in USA and Bangladesh Supreme Courts reversing reservations has spurred a debate once again on "merit reservation". Dr. Amartya Sen appreciates reservation as necessary but not sufficient to a comprehensive approach based on capability approach needed.