Examine the merits and demerits of a coalition government in the context of India. (15 marks)
Vikas, AIR 27, 2025
Robert called coalitions as "power sharing arrangements" where different political parties come together to form the government and share power.
Going by systems approach of David Easton, political systems are shaped by elements in environment. Considering the pragmatic nature of Indian society with huge diversity and a federal polity established by constitution, coalitions are natural for a country like India.
In 1951-67 phase, Congress acted as a "Rainbow coalition" as per Rajni Kothari by accommodating various interest. Paul Process called INC as a "coalition of parties".
In 1967-89 phase, we saw regionalisation of politics with the big political parties at regional level. It led to confrontation between National and State parties leading to a "policy paralysis". Constitutional provisions like Art.356, post of Governor came under criticism in 1980's. Regional parties emerged as "kingmakers".
In 1989-2014 era of coalition politics, "coalition dharma" was not seen in coalitions as held by former PM. A.B. Vajpayee. Oversized "coalitions" based on Political calculations and not based on ideology brought instability in national politics in 1990's with India seeing multiple PM's. It led to policies of defections, "Aaya Ram Gaya Ram" and promoted "Horse Trading in politics.
However scholars like M.P. Singh appreciate coalition governments for strengthening federalism as "in era of coalition politics, federalism was declared as "basic structure" of the constitution [Bommai case]. Democratic decentralisation in form of 73rd and 74th Amendment took place. Scholars like Yogendra Yadav held that coalition governments with involvement of regional parties made federalism more representative and pluralistic". Sudha Pai believed coalition governments made democracy more representative and consociational.
In country like India, with return of era of coalition government in 2024 elections, we have to think about how to make coalition work by introducing "constructive vote of confidence" and bring coalition government under the "tenth schedule".