पूंजीवादी और समाजवादी अर्थव्यवस्थाओं में राज्य की विशेषताओं की तुलना कीजिए। Compare the characteristics of the State in capitalist and socialist economies.
Apurva Verma, AIR 42, 2025
The state in capitalist and socialist economies can be differentiated on the basis of who controls the mode of production. In a capitalist nation, states are aligned with bourgeoisie class.
A capitalist state does not exist in vacuum. The prevailing socio-political environment impacts its functioning. In a capitalist society, since mode of production is privatized; state's role varies from night watchmans to welfare roles depending on prevailing condition.
State ensures rights and equality of opportunity to safeguard rights of capitalists. When contradictions emerge, state goes for welfare measures to accomodate the sub-alterns (concept of hegemony).
In a socialist economy, there is a need for centralised planning. State is at the core of all functions. It controls the degree of rights and focus is more on duty. Equality is supposed to be substantive based on providing resources based on "need". A socialist state ensures the control over mode of production with people. However, success varies and till now it has not proved to be very efficient.
In real, we need a mix of traits of both socialist and capitalist state for the most practicable form.