Topper Copies

Governor is neither a saboteur nor a sage; he is a constitutional functionary who needs to be solely loyal to the Constitution. Critically examine the statement in the light of recent events.

Zinnia Aurora, AIR 6, 2025

Governor, a constitutional conduit in our sui-generis federal polity, is a functionary of crucial importance.

Functionary - not saboteur/sage 1. Conduit and interface between Union and state. - (eg) communication facilitator. 2. Nominal executive of state - keeps real executive in check. - (eg) breach of constitutional scheme reported to union 3. Approver of state legislative decisions - avoiding harsh, paced decisions. - (eg) Presidential reference in certain bills. 4. Chancellorship of state universities under state's guidance. - (eg) Kerala Governor's case against appointment of VCs. 5. Declaration of Presidents' Rule on Governor's report (Art 356) -> reports on constitutional breakdown

Saboteur - Bills kept indefinitely to exercise pocket veto - Initiation of President's Rule - Disruption of sessions of legislative assembly with inaugural session ceremony - (eg) Tamil Nadu. - Chancellorship rights fight between Governor and state - (eg) Kerala, Tamil Nadu - Non declaration of money bills on advice of council of ministers.

Reforms have, thus, been suggested 1. Sarkaria Commission - de-link appointment from Union - autonomous functionary with no ties to centre. - deadline-based legislative powers - "localised emergencies" only in affected areas 2. Punchhi Commission - integrity of procedure of appointment - discretionary bandwidth explicitly defined. - Report to constitution, not centre - appointment committee with security of tenure is crucial.

Thus, to enhance constitutional loyalty of gubernatorial office, it is important to advance the commissions' reforms, herein.