"Finance Commission must think afresh conceptually, methodologically, and operationally." Explain in the context of the recently constituted 16th Finance Commission.(10 Marks)
Vikas, AIR 27, 2025
Finance commission, established under Article 280 is called as "Balancing wheel of fiscal federalism" in India.
Recently 16th finance commission has been set up under Arvind Panagariya for making recommendations for the period of 2026-31.
Here has been a need to think afresh by the finance commission conceptually, it has to ensure the fiscal federalism principle to ensure sufficient funds to the states and local bodies as Vijay Kelkar held "fiscal federalism" is oxygen to the overall federalism in India.
Methodologically, it has to suggest principles of distributions based on needs and availability of finances to both centre and States. Issues like debt-ceilings on the States as recommended by Finance Commission has become a bone of contention between centre & State like in recently dispute between Kerala and centre in supreme court.
Operationally, It has to include the perspective of states in making its recommendations. P.K.Singh called for further consultation with the States for formation and working mechanism of finance commission. he suggested a synchronisation in working of finance commission and G.S.T council for better fiscal federalism. He also suggested to make finance commission a 'permanent body' for more efficient & effective functioning