Topper Copies

Mill was a champion of democracy who failed to bring the idea of democracy to its logical conclusion. Critically examine

Nikita Verma, AIR 30, 2025

It is said that J.S. Mill is a reluctant democrat. Though he was a proponent of direct democracy, he supported representative democracy due to its practical efficiency.

Mill believes that:-

1. Representative democracy where possible 2. Benevolent despotism for colonies.

Mill is not keen on expanding democracy to the colonies as he believes education, literacy, ownership of property is a pre-requisite. He is criticised for his beliefs.

Apart from this, even for democracy in Britain he proposes "reforms". Due to universal suffrage more poor people were getting right to vote which could lead to "Government of Ignorants."

Thus, he proposes safeguards:-

1. Weighted voting 2. Right to Representation for property in every state 3. More powers to House of Lords.

Thus, he isn't sure of the future of democracy even in countries like Britain.

Thus, it is said that though Mill was a champion of democracy who failed to bring democracy to its logical conclusion. His fears were true because many democracies have turned into mobocracies.

But the only solution to the problem is awareness among the people of their rights, liberties.