Topper Copies

"The only freedom which deserves the name is that of pursuing our own good in our own way..." - J.S. Mill. Comment

Nikita Verma, AIR 30, 2025

It is said that if anyone is liberal it was J.S. Mill. J.S. Mill is credited to have brought the tradition of liberty back in liberalism. Before him, utilitarianism had dominated liberty.

Mill is a consistent thinker for his advocacy for liberty. He believes that state should give maximum opportunity to man to develop his potential and achieve the best. As Mill writes "NO STATE BECOMES GREAT BY DWARFING ITS OWN CITIZEN."

Mill believes that liberty is good not only for the individual but for the state also. It helps state accrue the maximum demographic potential.

To determine the limits on Liberty, Mill has given the HARM PRINCIPLE. Mill classifies human actions into two types:-

1. Self regarding 2. Other regarding

For him, state has no right to interfere in self regarding actions, but it can interfere in other regarding actions. State can stop a person from drinking & driving.

Critics like Ernest Barker refer Mill as the prophet of empty liberty for his abstract classification as self regarding & other regarding.

Apart from this, Barker is a positive liberal who believes freedom is in the presence of state.

But, it is to be noted that J.S. Mill is an active proponent of liberty. He believed that this should be extended to women and this, also seen in his support to suffragette movement.