Topper Copies

"Gramsci gives us not the tools with which to solve the puzzle, but the means with which to ask right kinds of questions" - Stuart Hall. Comment

Nikita Verma, AIR 30, 2025

Gramsci belonged to the troubled phase of Italy i.e under Fascist Mussolini. He was deeply pained to look at the condition of poor & their exploitation at the hands of BOURGEOISE class.

Gramsci was a marxist & like Marx he wanted to bring Revolution.

But unlike Marx, who gave "SCIENTIFIC REVOLUTION" which comprises the steps to be followed for revolution.

Gramsci goes deeper & questions why communist revolution failed in capitalist economies like Britain but happened in semi feudal society like USSR.

Marx was a determinist who called for PROLETARIAT REVOLUTION but Gramsci, a theoretician of superstructure has given us not the tools for revolution but the questions for the failure & prospective solution.

His analysis points out that the reason for failure of communist revolution in Italy was that it was an OPAQUE SOCIETY. The capitalist intellectuals & state created their hegemony which prevented revolution's success.

Thus, a protracted war is needed against the capitalist.

As Stuart points out that it is Gramsci who kept communism relevant especially after the rise of Nazi Germany & fascist Italy.