Topper Copies

While realism focuses on the mechanisms of state behaviour, Marxism focuses on the underlying economic and social forces. Evaluate the statement using examples.

Rakhi, AIR 65, 2025

Realism is regarded as the archetectonic theory of International Relations, with its ideas being a footnote for other theories.

The idea of realism focuses on state and its rise in power, which entails war as inevitable, as provided by Thucydides Trap. This was also seen as paradigm shift after the second world war in philosophy of Thomas Kuhn, leading to failure of liberal world order, which had man as central actor.

The most prominent realist scholar, Morgenthau, projected state as power seeking due to nature of human as Animal Dominadi. He also projected the primary aim of state's foreign policy to protect national interest. He eschewed the idea of any presence of ideology ("yur on illusion") and absence of ethics in politics, establishing autonomy of state and politics, similar to Machiavelli.

Moreover, neorealist such as Kenneth Waltz and Mearsheimer considered anarchy as the main reason of war, which allows the state to either seek defense (Balance of Power) or offense (Buckpassing) to promote national interest.

However, this theory has been criticised by Marxist scholar for being too state centric and ignoring the needs of non-dominant class.

Thus, as per Marx, economy forms the base and state is part of the superstructure. The theory of 'development of underdeveloped' by Ag franke and S. Amin, focuses on the presence of neo-colonialism, which has led to domination of developed and western states for economic gains. Lenin, in his Theory of Imperialism also emphasis this as part of capitalism and need of coming together of workers of colonies for ending capitalism.

Immanuel Wallerstein, in his World Systems Theory, addressed the interlinkage of countries on economic basis i.e. core nations subjugating the peripheral and semi-peripheral states.

Moreover Structural Marxist such as Gramsci, also focuses on social forces as a means to establish the legitimacy of ruling class, which is based on civil society, media, religions and institutions by developing consent and leading to international peace.

Thus, realist focus on national interest, whereas Marxist focus on interest of subaltern class, which are socially and economically deprived as was also mentioned by post colonial scholars such as Edward Said, Homi Bhabha, requiring for a hybrid culture.