Topper Copies

Analyse the historical approach to studying comparative politics.

Rakhi, AIR 65, 2025

Comparative Politics refers to comparing the constitutional and political system of different nations which find its origin in Aristotle, where he studied 158 constitutions, by their scientific analysis.

The comparative politics follows two major approaches i.e. Traditional and Behavioural. The traditional approach developed after Treaty of Westphalia in 1648 and active till 1919. Within this, normative, empirical, historical, legal-institutional are major approaches.

The historical approach considers the basis of history to study the human nature and functioning of state. The major scholars within this school was Machiavelli, who relied on history to determine human nature i.e. thinking shows that humans are selfish, fickle minded, avaricious, coward, jealous.

The similar analysis was done by Marx, where he used historical materialism to look at economic models i.e. evolution from primitive, feudal, slave society to capitalist society, which is bound to be replaced by communism. This was inspired by Hegel's Historical Idealism.

However, it has been criticised for being class [?] and eurocentric, with focus on western nations.

Yet, it is useful method, used also in India by Gandhi (Gandhians are bound to win as they are on right side of history).