Discuss how Antonio Gramsci has influenced Marxist theorists of cultural and political domination in developed capitalism.
Animesh Jain, AIR 63, 2025
Marxist theory of political domination in developed capitalism was based on base and superstructure model given by Karl Marx. As per this economic forces form the base and political structure like state form the superstructure.
The superstructure is influenced by base i.e mode and forces of production shaped domination in society. Thus Bourgeoisie rule over proletariat because of its economic dominance.
However, Marxist theory failed to explain no emergence of socialist revolution in capitalist societies as predicted by Marx. This dilemma was solved by Antonio Gramsci.
Gramsci started Neo-Marxism. His work are known through his prison notebook. First he argued that superstructure has autonomy of its own. It comprise of civil society and political state. Thus not just base shape superstructure but superstructure also shape the base.
The role of civil society as per Gramsci is to build hegemony. Hegemony defines the limits of common sense. It builds consent among the masses. Hegemony is build through institutions like school, family, church etc. communism could not succeed in Western capitalist societies because of hegemony of capitalist ideas.
Thus he highlights role of cultural factors and stopped criticism of Marxism as economic reductionism. He suggests role of 'organic intellectuals' to challenge this hegemony. Leaders/managers in factories could play the role of organic intellectuals. they should develop "revolutionary consciousness" among proletariat. Thus "war of position" has to precede "war of movement".
Gramscian thoughts inspired critical school scholars like Theoder Adorno, Max Horkheimer and Robert Cox. They highlight role of "culture factory" in shaping capitalist hegemony in West. Herbert Marcuse concept of "one dimensional Man" also shows how capitalism promote consumerism and Man forgets his own exploitation.
Gramsci's contribution can be understood from Chantal Mouffe statement that "we have entered the era of Gramscianism in the theory of Marxism".