Topper Copies

Although upholding the spirit of the Constitution through judicial activism is noble in its intent, in practice it runs the risk of undermining the delicate balance of power that the Constitution sought to achieve. Critically examine.

Zinnia Aurora, AIR 6, 2025

Judiciary, a crucial spoke of the Indian republic, is the guarantor of rights and promulgator of "Rule of Law".

Constitutionally spirited activism (intent for change) + (suo moto justice initiation) = activism for change

1. Facilitates constitutional morality - (eg) true meaning of "justice" via Article 142. 2. Relaxed locus standi for aiding public redressal - (eg) Bhagwati's PIL mechanics for undertrials' rights. 3. Going the "extra mile" for effecting equal protection of law. 4. Protection against arbitrary actions of the state - (eg) Champakam Dorairajan's land case. 5. Pressurizing government to uphold freedom and equality - (eg) Union's "role" in declaring rights for LGBTQIA+ community 6. Safeguarding constitutional fences in federal dispensation - (eg) Verdict on Tamil Nadu's Bill barrier of gubernatorial office. 7. Provision of executive accountability in fear of judicial teardown. - (eg) coalgate scam.

However, an overreach of sorts, into other organs' functionality is alleged, thus vitiating Montesquieu's separation of powers.

1. Judicial legislation - (eg) Place of Worship Act, all properties opened to by SC. 2. Executive action and rule-making by judiciary, instead of directive to state. - (eg) disabled people's rights and rules for documentation. 3. Expansion of rights, without Parliamentary approval - (eg) Article 21 and 19. 4. Undermining Parliament's sovereignty by bringing exclusive powers under self. - (eg) Delimitation now under judicial review.

Judicial pero-activism, balanced on constitutional principles, can yield beyond mere pedantic legalism