The ongoing debate on euthanasia poses several ethical questions. Discuss.
Aditya Srivastava, AIR 1, 2023
Euthanasia is the right of a person to choose to die voluntarily. Recent case of woman stopping her friend from travelling abroad for euthanasia revived the debate.
Ethical arguments for euthanasia
1. Right to bodily autonomy of the person 2. Compassion towards the person if in vegetative state. (Eg) Aruna Shanbaug case 3. Right to choice which is an essential component of empowerment 4. State interference in private sphere by disallowing euthanasia → against Hobbesian Social contract
Ethical arguments against euthanasia
1. Person may not be in a state to give consent → violation of Article 21 (right to life) 2. Right to life does not include the right to die 3. State has a role of upholding welfare of all and utilitarianism 4. Allowing euthanasia loosely can be a slippery slope 5. Can be misused for vested interests. (Eg) Euthanising parents to get property
Need of the hour is to have a balanced approach in line with Aristotle's Golden Mean to allow Euthanasia with strict safeguards for ethical usage.