Topper Copies

Plato is concerned about any thought that offers the ruling authority to common individuals. Comment.

Animesh Jain, AIR 63, 2025

Plato is the father of political philosophy. His book "Republic" deals with the affairs of city state. In this, he gives the idea of 'philosopher king' to make Athens great vis a vis sparta. He exercise supreme authority. He is embodiment of knowledge and virtue.

Plato's theory of philosopher king is based on "Myth of Metal". Human race is divided into men of copper, silver and gold. Men of copper have appetite, Men of silver has courage and Men of gold have reason. Philosopher king is a man of gold i.e reason dominates.

Thus common individuals i:e men of copper are not suited to rule since they don't have reason. Rule by common man i:e democracy would be disastrous for the state. The only solution is "rule of reason" i:e philosopher king. In words of Plato:

"Until philosophers are king or king turn philosophy, there is no solution to predicament of human life".

He gives theory of education to identify the philosopher king. It is a 50 year process of training to find best suitable man. His theory of justice is based on all elements of soul being at right place i:e performing the function they are meant to perform.

However, Plato's disciple Aristotle criticises the rule of philosopher king. He suggest polity as best practicable. This is rule of middle class.

Aristotle argue that even philosopher king have appetite and can't be trusted with supreme power.

Aristotle also argue for rule of law over one person. In his words -> "law is reason without passion", thus rule of law should be supreme. However, even Aristotle failed to give power to masses. He opposed democracy and favoured polity as "middle golden mean".

For his theory of Philosopher King, Plato was criticised as fascist and totalitarian by Karl popper. He is called 'enemy of open societies'.

Though philosopher king is incompatible with idea of Modern day democracy based on mass participation, it provides a unique framework to think about governance. We find similarities in idea of Plato and Buddha. For Buddha too, king was akin a philosopher.

As Whitehead rightly observes, entire political science, is nothing but footnotes of Plato and Aristotle.