"There is a complex and, in many ways, ambivalent relationship between liberalism and multiculturalism." Discuss.
Animesh Jain, AIR 63, 2025
Liberalism as an philosophy is based on ideas of respect for 'rational' individuals and equality among all citizens. It stands for universal citizenship i.e equal right for all citizens.
However universal citizenship of liberalism was criticised by Multi-cultural scholars like Will kymlicka and Bhikhu Parekh as 'color blindness'. In name of universal citizenship, Community rights are violated. This can be seen in debate around Hijab wearing rights in France. In name of protecting women right, the state violates their religious right.
These scholars give the solution of 'Multicultural Citizenship'. This is based on: special representation, community rights and grievance redressal.
Community rights should be protected especially if they do not directly feed to violence against people.
However, this model can lead to violation of rights. Liberal feminists criticise multicultural citizenship for violating rights of women. Inhuman practices like Triple talaq, temple entry ban can be justified in name of multiculturalism.
other liberal scholars like Amartya Sen argue that multiculturalism leads to ghettoisation and stalls progress in society. Cosmopolitan scholars like David Held argue that it helps emergence of global citizenship.
Some scholars like Bruce Bawer argue for not be tolerant towards intolerant. In "Appeasing Islam, sacrificing freedom", he blames multiculturalism for causing decline of liberal value in West.
Thus liberalism and multiculturalism have a complex relations. While some liberal scholars recognise respect for cultural differences, others see it as a threat to liberal values themselves.