Compare Rawls and Amartya Sen's views on Justice.
Animesh Jain, AIR 63, 2025
Justice is a key concept in political science since the times of Plato and Aristotle. Rawls and Amartya Sen have enriched the concept through their ideas.
Rawls give a Procedural model of Justice. People in veil of Ignorance arrive at three principles of Justice in lexical order:
1. Maximum equal liberty. 2. equality of opportunity 3. Difference principle, help least advantaged.
His theory is thus of 'justice with fairness'. Inequality in society is justice only when it helps least advantaged.
Amartya Sen criticises Rawls theory on ground that there can be no universal principles of justice. Original position is not practically possible since men is embedded in society.
He explains this through a exempl. of flute -> who can play it, Carl has made it and another child is poor. Now to whom to give the flute? we cannot decide this without doing injustice to someone.
However Sen argues that it is easy to identify injustice. Focus on tackling that. It is a substantive model of justice i.e Nyaya. Sen suggest capacity building approach to ensure true justice.
People will be able to realise their potential when they hav the capability to use the resources available.
Thus Rawls theory is more theoretical, Sen's theory is practical and action oriented. Rawls theory is procedural while Sen give substantive theory. Rawls theory is for hypothetical individuals. Sen's theory is for real individuals in real life.
Theory of Justice given by both Rawls and Sen has led to revival of political philosophy and has helped in making liberal societies more humane.