Topper Copies

Analyse the 'crisis tendencies' found in liberal democracies that threaten the legitimacy of the regimes.

Animesh Jain, AIR 63, 2025

The theory of legitimacy was given by Max Weber. legitimacy means respect for authority by the people. This occurs when people sees state's rule as helpful for their own development.

liberal democracy's legitimacy rests on the promise of life of liberty and dignity to the people. Provisions like freedom of speech and expression, social security, affirmative action, capacity building etc are made to ensure 'good life'.

Despite this, many liberal democracies today suffer from 'legitimisation crisis' in word of Habermas. There are multiple reasons for this - First is rising inequalities especially after new-liberalism era has generated discontent among have nots. This was evident in movements like Occupy Wall Street, 1% vs 99% etc.

Another connected phenomenon is rise of plutocracy - in words of Pratap Bhanu Mehta, state is increasingly being seen to be working for elites instead of masses. This has led to rise of Right wing leaders like Victor Orban in Hungary & Trump in USA.

Globalisation has also impacted legitimacy due to job losses and illegal immigration. Trump's America first, Re-Shoring / friend shoring and ban on migrations are a sign of rising influence towards globalisation.

From Marxist perspective also, Socialism in economies and capitalism in politics can't continue for long. welfare measures are leading to rising debt levels and thereby imposition of austerity measures. This leads to rolling back of the state causing further discontent.

Multi-culturalism is also testing the limits of liberal democracies. They are finding it hard to balance individual and community rights. Use of state coercion is seen as violence by minorities eroding state's legitimacy.

Even pressure of global politics is testing liberal societies. USA's crackdown on anti-Israeli protesters in its universities shows illiberal trends in USA. This has raised questions on health of USA's democracy itself.

Despite above challenges, the state remains in command. There is no sign of mass scale uprising against state in liberal societies. This can be attributed to Gramscian hegemony through use of civil society to contain crises.

Nonetheless, liberal states should evolve to answer the crises by making growth more inclusive, participative and transparent along with going for global cooperation to tackle shared challenges.