Topper Copies

Critically examine Samuel Huntington's 'Clash of Civilizations' thesis.

Animesh Mishra, AIR 428, 2025

'Clash of Civilisation' is a construct given by Samuel P Huntington to explain the post-cold war order. He argues that the future order is going to be determined by conflict among civilizations and not ideologies.

According to Huntington, 'identity' is innate part of man's personality. Hence, the ideologies may change but identity is static.

It helps us to explain conflict among China-USA as conflict of civilization for identity reasons.

The conflict among Palestinians and Jews is also a conflict of identity and not of 'self-determination' and right to nation state with dignity as painted by Edward Said.

Further conflict of Armenia-Azerbaijan, Indo-China, India-Pakistan are all out of conflict of identity. This adds the 'determinism' to Huntington's thesis.

However, 'the theory' is not accurate depiction of order. It is parsimonious explanation of the global order.

Realist point to structural contribution of anarchy that contribute to conflict of power among great powers.

Idealists points to reconciliation among civilisations like Chinese-Islamic, Hindu-Islamic etc. in the real world showing 1 reason may triumph civilisational conflicts.

Further, the theory does not explain civil wars within nations like [?] (Tigray vs. Oromo) or the demand for separate state ex: Baluchistan from Pakistan despite sharing identity.

Hence, the theory is a demonstration of Knowledge-power connection and seeks to impose a Eurocentric notion of world which is 'unscientific'.

Yet, it is useful in understanding a contradictory role in the motivations of states ex: Russia's sense of identity. Hence, IR politics using multiple approach helps.