Critically examine the Democratic Peace Theory, and discuss whether democracy promotion in developing societies is feasible.
Animesh Mishra, AIR 428, 2025
Democratic peace Theory was propounded by [Michael Doyle] in 'Ways of war and peace'. He postulated that the democracies in international system never go at war.
The philosophical basis was [Kant's] 'Perpetual peace', when he argued that promoting republicanism creates culture of toleration and prevents use of violence to resolve conflict.
Moreover, due to public opinion being important for state's legitimacy, no state would want to go for war as it is unpopular.
This theory was also reinforced by [Spencer Weart] work 'Never at war', by analysing republics and their foreign policy, concluding that democracy never engage in conventional conflict. Thus, making democracy a normatively desired goal.
However, Realist like Mearsheimer argue that regardless of the political system, all states would go for power maximisation.
Feminists Post-colonial scholars would argue that it promotes 'military humanism' and interventionist foreign policy ex: Afghanistan.
Marxists point to how this logic is used to justify bourgeoisie democracy for coup to form democracy ex: Latin America coup, chile coup by USA.
Democracy promotion in developing societies: No, it is not feasible, as JS Mill would argue that they do not have democratic culture leading to mobocracy.
Lee Kwan Yew would argue that it is a western value and would not work in East where authority is important.
Similarly, post-colonial proponents would point to need to allow agency to decide any political system which suits the nation.
However, as Amartya Sen pointed in Development in Freedom that even in developing society it can be promoted ex: Rwanda.
CB Macpherson also rejected liberal monopoly over democracy and believed even developing nation can be democratic.
Hence democracy is an impulse promoting justice and dignity and delivering 'good life' to people.