Topper Copies

Compare and contrast between Marxist and feminist view on State.

Arpit Kumar, AIR 421, 2024

Earlier held State as central concept of political science. In post-westphalian order State form an inherent model in order of 'nation state' thus having sovereign powers in the social contract.

Marxism, starting from Karl Marx's historical materialism, considers State as executive agency of bourgeoisie as being in super-structure. Simultaneously, feminist scholars like Catherine Mckinnon in 'towards feminist theory of state' opines that 'when i look at state it appears male to me'.

For Marx if economic structure is found as basic structure, for feminist like Carole pateman, patriarchy forms the basic structure.

Karl Marx's 'Theory of Alienation' calls for 'existence as prior to essence' and intellectualism as false consciousness of plato. Even Jean Paul Sartre holds similar view in 'existence over essence' as 'in existence man is subject but in essence it becomes object'.

Similarly in international sphere, dependency theorist feel that State of developed world has lead to inequalities of not only their own countries but other countries like African countries as shown by A.G frank's 'development of underdevelopment'. Similarly feminist scholar like Carole pateman in 'Banana, Beaches and bases' highlight how States have used women even for sexual slavery, for forex earning.

And one more similarity occur in socialist feminist like Shulamith firestone where she considers 'private property' as reason for exploitation of women.

But coming out of similarities, there are differences like feminists in '[?] tradition' 'personal is political' wants state to empower feminists. Marxist on other hand wants complete stateless and classless society.

While marxism completely delinated from liberal model of democracy, Liberal feminist like Mary wollstonecraft and Hariet tailor opined for civil and political right for women.

Both marxism and feminism are the ideology of vulnerable. The modern eco-feminism of Vandana Shiva and eco-marxists hold the similar thought that states exploit environment for sake of capitalism.