Topper Copies

Compare and contrast Arthashastra tradition and the 'Realist' tradition represented by Machiavelli.

Arpit Kumar, AIR 421, 2024

Political realism, though both in western and eastern civilization may differ temporally, but showcase mutually converging and with exception diverging ideas.

In east with 'Kautilyan Arthashastra' and in west by 'Prince' of Nicole Machiavelli we see similarities occuring throughout thesis. To support this, Pt. Nehru in 'discovery of India' even calls "Kautilya as 'Indian Machiavelli'".

For similarity, both were rid of political corruption rampant in state. Both Italy and Nanda empire showcased corruption thoroughly entrenched from elites to the common subject.

Similarly, Machiavellian idea of prince to be 'clever as fox and brave as lion' found similarity with Chanakya gupta's ideal of concentrating all three forms of Kautilyan power, i.e Prabhushakti, Mantra Shakti and Utsahshakti.

Thirdly, we see a great emphasis on 'Monarchy' by both school of thought. A common aversiveness from Nobles as they concentrate power harming the interest of nation.

Fourthly, in foreign policy, a sphere of expansionist foreign policy is there. While Machiavelli provided strict instructions for realism in International relations, Kautilya provided explanations like 'Mandala-Siddhanta', '4 upayas', 'Shadguna niti' and 'Saptanga theory'.

Despite these similarities, we witnessed some differences. For machiavellian prince, religion was a tool to be used in 'dual morality' for fulfilling National interest i.e 'raison de etat'. But in kautilyan magnum opus, King is not above Dharma.

Moreover, kautilyan explanations are more descriptive than Machiavelli. Even Kautilya got his prince during his lifetime unlike Machiavelli. Kautilyan Arthashastra also included diverse segments like corruption, economics, spies framework which is missing in 'The prince'.

Upinder Kaur credits Pt. Nehru by calling Machiavelli as italian Kautilya. In modern day Russia-Ukraine war, crisis of modernity, political corruption, Wintonitz and Bottazzi rightly quote from Machiavelli to Kautilya to explore roots of realism.