Topper Copies

Explain the idea of 'state of nature'. How has the difference between Hobbes' and Locke' 'state of nature' impacted their respective conceptions of the state?

Arpit Kumar, AIR 421, 2024

'State of Nature' is an hypothetical concept which is utilized by political thinkers to provide for the necessity of their theory by explaining human conduct and hinderances which it faces in absence of quoted political solutions.

Both Locke and Hobbes in 'treatise on civil government' and 'Leviathan' simultaneously explains the state of Nature in different ways.

For Hobbes, due to his first hand experience of puritan revolution of Britain feels that human nature is utilitarian, individualistic, materialistic and possessive. For him, passion dominates the man.

For locke, being firm [?] of "glorious revolution", saw that even peaceful transfer of power can happen. He maintains the ability of reason and passion as equal and ability of human to understand each other's needs and cooperate for harmonious society.

For the kind of State, hobbes in Leviathan provides for monistic theory of state by providing absolute power to sovereign. Locke on other hand, gives concept of 'civil society' and 'majoritarian represented' state paving way for representative democracy.

In linkage to this, Hobbes provide 'Right to life' to all the individual and ability to revolt, if this right were under threat. Locke, father of political liberalism, provides for right of Life, liberty and property to individuals and state only playing role of night watchman state.

And lastly regarding religion, Hobbes going away from 'theory of multiple swords of medieval' times puts religious institution under the State. Locke, however in his concept of tolerance provides for tolerant behaviour towards religion in personal sphere without intervention.

In above segments we saw political science as master science, as claimed by Aristotle, builds itself on state of Nature and explains a theory which is mainly oriented towards a class interest and State-citizen relationship.

Karl Mannheim in 'Sociology of knowledge' rightly explains that every theory has a social base which supports those ideas. The Anarchism we witness in Hobbesian idea is shown as enlightened anarchism in gandhian sphere of Hind Swaraj.

Both Locke and Hobbes gets criticism. Locke from Filmer for taking away generational rights while Hobbes for being an absolutist regarding State power by C.B Macpherson.

Still, their theories form basis on which scholars like Karl Marx, Hannah Arendt develop their explanations.