Deliberative democracy does not have its salience without participation and participatory democracy does not have its credence without deliberation. Comment.
Arpit Kumar, AIR 421, 2024
"Democracy in it's very meaning is deliberative. Any discussion with participation is not a stumbling block but an important aspect of democratic functioning" - Pericles.
Deliberative democracy does not have salience without participation
For deliberation, we require an efficient participation of people. Since Aristotle's civic republicanism and Hannah Arendt's Vita Activa it has been an important aspect of people coming together.
In deliberations too, voice of individual matter. Rousseau held that English men are only once free in five years; this means that participation is only limited to election. One of the criticism of modernity is people moving away from political sphere and not participating.
This lack of participation reduces the power in the hands of few. The social counting principle provides for aggregate and not authentic choices and democracy becomes representative but not deliberative.
Participatory democracy -> deliberation
While participating, since Socrates the great emphasis has been laid on dialectics. Even J.S Mill held that in a participatory democracy, every minority should be given the right to speak.
The participatory methods of referendum, plebiscite, recall provides avenue of deliberation among people. Amartya Sen has rightly highlighted that government will not listen without deliberation.
Even Joshua Cohen highlights and links that in deliberative democracy to maintain constancy, the availability of quality citizens is a must.
[?] utilized in 'political culture' approach by Almond and Verba that over participation may lead to ghettoization of democracy. But as we see, that recently Election commission of India placed a poll booth at the highest point in Himachal and still it saw 100% polling.
This showcases a combination of deliberation and participation moves of democracy from 'Nehruvian' to 'Nyaya'.