How does instrumentalist approach differ from Relative Autonomy approach in Marxist theory of state?
Arpit Kumar, AIR 421, 2024
Marxism which evolved from Karl Marx and Engels' 'communist manifesto' dreams of a classless and stateless society. It provides a critical analysis of capitalism on how it functions and dominates.
Taking cue from historical materialism, dialectical materialism, theory of surplus value many meta schools in marxism has developed. Instrumentalist and Relative Autonomy school are two such school.
For relation between State and capitalists, Instrumentalist school provided by Ralph Miliband held 'State as executive agency of bourgeoisie'. However, structural marxists which develop their methodology from 'multistructural
Pluralists holds that in certain cases State become relatively autonomous when there are more than one pressure group.
Regarding role of Universal democracy, Instrumentalist feel it as just another method of maintaining hegemony. However Structuralist like Nicos Poulantzas highlight that workers getting right to vote, political manifestoes to appease all classes has increased their bargaining power.
Moreover, in definition, Instrumentalist school asserts from Communist manifesto. However for Structuralists main motivation emerges from Karl Marx's "18th Brumaire" of Louis Bonaparte which state how Napoleon got extra powerful in presence of feudal, capitalist and religious class.
And lastly in methodology, Instrumentalist and later dependency theorist upheld how A.G Frank's 'development of underdevelopment' occured in Africa. But in Structural school the multi-dimensional analysis of over-developed state of Hamza Alavi provides great explanations.
Both have issues, where Instrumentalist goes for crude economic determinism, and Structuralist makes multidimensionality as complex and completely removes the human factor as criticized by Frankfurt marxist.
Yet both school, Instrumentalist in Samir Amin's 'imperialist rent' and Structuralist in Louis Althusser's 'concept of interpellation' provides unique insights.