Multicultural perspective on Rights limits the scope of a Universal conception of Rights. Comment.
Arpit Kumar, AIR 421, 2024
Multiculturalism opined idea of Special minority rights for individuals in modern construct of Nation State. It mainly emerged due to non-scientific boundary redrawing, refugee coming and inter-nation migration.
It mainly starts with Will Kymlicka's Multiculturalism; 'A liberal theory of minority rights'. It suggested special self governance, self representation and cultural rights for minorities.
However, it does goes against a universal conception of Rights. Such rights might create ghettoization in a country as held by Amartya Sen. The special treatment given to a sect may leave them stranded in societal reverse discrimination.
Even some rights are so universalistic that even culture cannot withhold them. Feminist like Betty friedman in 'feminine mystique' held that every culture has patriarchy as its basic Structure. This necessitates universal rights of woman and not leaving them at hand of mercy of culture.
Even, how to define culture in itself is ambiguous. Chandra Kukathas highlight that there might be 'minority within minorities'. A specific set of rights for a section may leave them estranged. This can be visible in case of homosexuals which are minority.
All things being said, the universal conception of rights is not free from discrimination. The concept is heavily biased in favour of liberal values. It [?] highlights the value monism prevalent in liberal conception of rights.
Moreover, lot of movements like #Black lives matter [?], islamophobic french movements show how liberal societies have not been able to accomodate the minorities. Even Kymlicka's theory negates such rights to refugees and migrants.
Attacking to it, Scholars of Asian values like Mahathir Mohammad highlight the liberal connotation of human rights as of 10 Dec 1948 have been used many times by USA for interfering in other countries eg Iraq, Vietnam etc.
So multiculturalism in its essence is, not bad. Bhikhu Parekh in "Rethinking multiculturalism" highlights the need of accomodating multicultural rights. For them the sustainable integration should be based on "harm principle" and "toleration" of Mill and Locke simultaneously.
For summing up, Raimon Panikkar rightly calls for "dialogical exchanges" of communities for mutual consensus without supremacy of one universal notion over another.