Discuss socialism before Marx. How has Karl Marx influenced Socialism?
Arpit Kumar, AIR 421, 2024
Thomas picketty in 'capitalism, socialism and democracy' highlights socialism as methodology of authoritative allocation of values by State in which they control factors of production and decide what to produce and how to distribute.
Socialism before Marx
Karl Marx held socialist before marx as 'utopians'. They believed in consciousness calling of the capitalists and simultaneously bargaining with the state for achieving socialist goals.
Louis Blanc, in his theory of revolution, provided revolution through education and parliamentary procedure for gaining the consciousness in the workers or middle class itself.
Similarly Robert Owen in his 'theory of cooperative' provide model of cooperative led socialism where people will come together by state initially participating in formation. Later on state will wither away and give space for workers led production.
Influence of Karl Marx
1. First, influence was inclusion of his scientific theory 'praxis' which involved the germ of revolution. This provided an alternative methodology to workers for gaining state control. 2. Secondly, through 'critique of political economy' his base-superstructure model established 'State as executive agency of Bourgeoisie'. So, Socialists has to find other way then State. 3. Thirdly, a humanistic critique of capitalism is formed in 'economic and philosophical manuscripts' which provides 'theory of Alienation' and shows this has made man one-dimensional (Jurgen Habermas). 4. And finally, a solution through 'war of position' and 'war of manoeuvre' by Gramsci for overall solution of marxist class-rule and state-rule socialism.
After Marx, many socialist paradigm like Fabian socialism, syndicalism, funcional socialism impacted lot for empowerment of school of thought.