Make a comparative assessment of Ambedkar's theory of social justice with that of Rawlsian idea of justice.
Arpit Kumar, AIR 421, 2024
"Justice is first virtue of any social system as truth is first virtue of any school of thought" - John Rawls in 'Theory of Justice'.
Both Rawls in American subcontinent and Ambedkar in South Asia emerge as colossus of social Justice. Their main emphasis lies on providing opportunity to down trodden and underprivileged one.
Differences
1. Ambedkar in 'Annihilation of caste' wants to remove all the social hierarchies based on caste system. Rawls on other hand wants to provide compensation for brute luck to left out individual. 2. While Rawls focus is on supremacy of liberty which he keeps at top in his lexical order, Ambedkar's main emphasis is on "State led development" which is visible in his work of democratic socialism. 3. While Rawls make a hypothetical veil of ignorance for coming up into a social contract, Ambedkar in his work 'Shudras' gives an anthropological account of creation of Untouchability and Antyaj. 4. Rawls being a social liberal wants a combination of State, market and society in his welfare model, and limits it in 'political Liberalism' to the political sphere. However, Ambedkar sees 'Social democracy should come prior to political democracy' and wants state intervention through voluntary means as seen in the VCC debate of the constitutional assembly.
However, there are similarities which can be found in Ambedkar and Rawls. Rawls wanted people to consider that they may be underprivileged in real world and make laws thoughtfully. A similar thing, Ambedkar held that if Bal gangadhar tilak would have been born untouchable he would have asked for "Annihilation of caste as my birth right".
In both of them we see the reverence towards constitutionalism which limits the power of State. The 'civil society' coming together for fair model is envisaged in both of them.
In contemporary times, we on one hand see Ambedkar's idea through reservation providing social justice and democratic upsurge (and Christopher Jaffrelot calls it as silent revolution). Similarly ideas of Rawls are used by policy makers like Douglas in technological sphere so as to provide limited surveillance and data rights by State.
Both Ambedkar and Rawls grow strong in present world culture for social equity and inclusiveness.