The office of the Speaker is not only a referee, but also an active player in the politics of government formation and survival, leading to controversies and criticisms. In this context, examine the need to bring reforms in the office of the speaker.
Zinnia Aurora, AIR 6, 2025
Office of Speaker is sine qua non to effective functioning of Lok Sabha, and has been borrowed from British tradition.
Active player 1. Final interpretor of constitution and Rules of House. - (eg) Hon'ble Om Birla on ethics committee report. 2. Decides heads of parliamentary committees and is head of any committee he joins. 3. Holds discretionary power in event of loss of confidence in ruling dispensation if no imminent successor. 4. Calls for floor test in case of confidence loss. - (eg) During Vajpayee ji's government fall. 5. Approves motions of substantive and other kinds that impact ruling government's stance and standing 6. Deciding authority on defection cases under Xth Schedule. - (eg) Maharashtra Assembly case. 7. No time-bound decision mandate by constitution of member's case at judgement - defection (overpowered by SC now). 8. Usage of Committees (quasi judicial) in member decorum behaviour - excesses alleged too. 9. Power to ratify money bills.
Reforms thus needed 1. Time-bound, dead-line based decision of defection. 2. Creation of matrix and committee vetting speakers' decisions (currently outside judicial review) 3. Impress on speaker being a non-party figurine, like British tradition
Thus, office of speaker, whilst a constitutionally affected power maverick has been conserved and restricted via checks and balances for an effective and discourse enabling Parliament.