Topper Copies

Write a note on the communitarian critique of the Rawlsian notion of justice.

Arpit Kumar, AIR 421, 2024

John Rawls in his book, 'A theory of Justice' provides for his theory which bases a purely procedural lexical order with max-min principle and hierarchy of:

1. Liberty 2. Equality of opportunity 3. Difference principle - Human dignity.

This concept of Justice was portrayed as universal by liberal school of thought. It mentioned to contain both procedural and substantive element which was obtained from 'veil of ignorance'.

However, Michael Sandler in 'limits of Justice' provides its communitarian critique. It states that Rawlsian idea overlooks that man is encumbered self. This means that all decisions of man are limited by his social conditions. They highlight that Rawls conception of liberty as priority is derived from his being from VAA.

They even consider that if Society is strongly willing for prosperity men will not require Justice. Similarly the complete overthrow of social customs and traditions and thicker veil of ignorance is not possible to be achieved.

Similarly, Michael walzer in 'Sphere of Justice' provides an alternative of Rawls democratic equality by 'complex equality'. In his words "every resource is to be distributed by different players for different reasons and different outcomes."

Though not communitarian, Amartya Sen too highlights the importance of social choice rather than liberal choice. He opines for inclusion of 'capacity development' of left out individuals.

Similarly, Rawls being a consequentialist, includes the idea of communitarianism in his work 'political liberalism'. It asserts for overlapping consensus of different people in political sphere. He leaves out personal sphere so as to maintain societal pluralism.

Still, Rawls theory forms important and has been used by Victoria [?] in America's healthcare system. Norman Barry highlights that Rawls is clearly a redistributionist as he balances the perks of meritorious with share of disadvantaged.