Topper Copies

'End of Ideology' thesis was an ideologically-driven project rather than objective assessment of political evolution of mankind. Comment.

Arpit Kumar, AIR 421, 2024

End of ideology thesis was propagated by Daniel Bell. It primarily emphasized on final solution of equality-liberty dictum and emergence of Ideological liberty as winner.

It highlighted how despite of following different models, all countries are going for capitalistic mode of development. It highlights China, India after Structural Adjustment programme and Russia after Shock therapy post 1991.

However Alasdair Macintyre holds that 'end of ideology' as an 'ideology in itself'. It mainly maintains Karl Mannheim's 'Sociology of knowledge' where scholars like AM Lipset are trying to maintain the dominance of liberalism.

In current scenario, Samuel P. Huntington's 'clash of civilization and remaking of the world order', we see that iron curtain of ideology has been replaced by velvet curtain of identity. Now the question has changed from Which side you are on? to Who are you? due to civilizational debates.

Even socialism though not completely passing the test, but has been an important aspect of functioning democracy. Social democratic party of USA, Beijing mode of socialism and countries like North Korea prompts a stark example.

The ideological parameter of level of ideology has mainly based on free market model of neo-liberal values. But in current context we see coming back of status in function and deteriorating phase of globalisation.

Pratap Bhanu Mehta opines that it is time for Swan song of globalisation. New movements of Anti-refugee campaigns, communitarian Asian values debate provide for a stark alternative to liberty.

Even in international domain the universal actors which portray liberal ideas of Woodrow Wilson are falling and facing crisis of legitimacy.

So, currently we see a thorough contrast between values like liberty, equality and sometimes new variants of them.