Topper Copies

Behaviouralism emerged as an attempt to rid political theory of its existing limitations, but it failed to transform political science into a problem-solving science. Discuss.

Arpit Kumar, AIR 421, 2024

Behaviouralism emerged as a movement from the works of David Easton in 1953, 'the political system'. It mainly emphasized on making political Science a pure Science distancing itself from 'old arm chair theories' which were prevalent during those times.

The limitations mainly included following features of traditional theory:-

1. Eurocentrism in framing theories 2. Inability to explain the emergence of fascism in inter-war period 3. Unable to explain functioning of post-colonial countries which FW Riggs considers as 'prismatic societies' 4. Over emphasis on history, law and overlooking of Science, Sociology etc.

Robert Dahl, considered political theory as dead. Charles Mariam from Chicago school emphasized on imparting value-neutrality and fact-based observation as basis of political Science.

The main model of behaviouralism emphasized on systematization, Transparency, verifiability, value-neutrality, measurement and most importantly 'pure-science'. It's contribution was developing of Stasiology, modern case study, electoral arithmetic to understand changes in political system.

However soon, Behaviouralism started falling short. Political Science started looking as sub-discipline of Sociology.

Moreover removal of normative aspects was not able to explain the ongoing Black protest, Civil wars of 1960's. Behaviouralism was reduced to 'pure-Scientific reductionism'.

David M-Ricci held that divorcing political science from normativeness is like taking away soul of human. Leo-Strauss upheld that removing values from pol science is like inability to differentiate between clean water and dirty water.

The problem solving science mainly became "ivory tower theories". David Easton in 'Credo of relevance' held that scientists became so emerged in perfecting the technique that they forget the purpose of political science.

David Easton gave principle of 'ethical neutrality and not value neutrality', 'greater responsibility of social scientist than natural scientist', continuum and 'inter-subject relationship' are must to keep on pol. science developing.

'Neo-institutionalism' of Theda Skocpol and 'A theory of justice' of John Rawls brought back normativism into philosophy.

The combination of both in modern times is considered as post-behaviouralism, which consists of both normative as well as scientific aspect.

Berlin rightly held that 'political theory is always alive as it has ability to come back from ashes to life.'