Explain Steven Lukes' Three dimensions of Power. How does it differ from Foucault's theory of Power?
Arpit Kumar, AIR 421, 2024
Power is regarded as core concept of modern day political science. It as explained by Robert Dahl is 'ability to change the outcome'. It can argued for making person do willingly or unwillingly what they may not do otherwise.
Steven Lukes provide a nuanced understanding of power. He ascertains 'power' as three things:
1. Decision making :- close to sovereignty 2. Agenda setting :- Marx's critique of capitalism 3. Thought control :- Gramsci's concept of hegemony
Lukes explain that by three methods State and authority gain legitimacy.
On other hand Foucault takes a Sociological view of power. He states that power is flowing through the society like blood in capillaries. It gives more multidimensional understanding of power.
In work, "Discipline and punish" he asserts three main modules of power:
1. Discipline :- new method of punishment replaced 2. Bio- :- homogenization 3. Governmentality :- from Bentham's panopticon (everyone is watching continuously)
The main difference occurs that while Lukes consider power to be in hands of State only, Foucault asserts that power is also with society and there is a continuous exchange going on.
Similarly Lukes methodology limits it initial understanding of power with capitalists and critiqued by marxists. Foucaults mainly links it with rationality as false consciousness through concept of archaeology.
Power emerging as meta-narrative has other important facets too. Scholars like Hannah Arundt in 'power as sui generis' feels that power is only with people and vita Aziva holds solution against evils of modernity.
'Power model and explanations may vary but also keep creative freedom and developmental power on its basis' says CB Macpherson.