How far do the theories of Equality and Justice reconcile with the Affirmative action policies of the states?
Arpit Kumar, AIR 421, 2024
Affirmative Action refers to extra efforts made on part of state to reduce the inequalities which may have occured due to historical injustice or lack of equal opportunity.
It is closely related with foundation model of equalizing with fairness. In his theory of Justice, the veil of ignorance after coming into a social contract there is a compensation for Brute luck. This comes close to idea of affirmative action.
Similarly, Dworkin in Sovereign Virtue offers his endowment insensitive and ambition sensitive auction, provide for compensation that too initially only for 'brute luck' and not 'option luck'.
Similarly in theories of equality, we see affirmative action being seeken for three different objectives:
1. Equality of outcome 2. Equality of resources 3. Equality of opportunity
Many social liberals like Amartya Sen favours the concept of Affirmative action as it in long term has shown improvements. UDHR watch report stated that inequality reduced in India after constitutional idea of Affirmative Action through Article 15 for women, children and SC/ST's.
Both combining form bed rock for positive liberty. T.H green held that every state is known for the right it maintain. They highly go for providing equality of opportunity and welfareist model of approach for justice.
But affirmative action, sees repercussions in societal paradigm. Many scholars like Robert Nozick in 'Anarchy, State and utopia' completely disregards it and favours 'rolling back of the state'.
William Sumner in his famous quote 'A drunkard in gutter is rightly where he belongs' goes against such idea of state interference. Even Liberal scholars like "Isaiah Berlin" calls for tolerance and avoidance of affirmative action as state may have government overstretched due to lack of resources and may appear biased to a section.
Recently, we saw US Supreme Court removing reservation of Blacks from the colleges and universities. However, this is not an encouragable model for west as Arun Maira in 'Billion butterflies' states that market control will make west an 'illiberal democracy'.
For better example, India's 106th amendment for 1/3rd rep. for women parliamentarians shows right combination of equality and justice for fairness.