Examine the challenges to sovereignty of the State in the contemporary world.
Arpit Kumar, AIR 421, 2024
Jean Bodin highlights Sovereignty as power of supreme authority over citizens and decisions which is only constrained by law. It includes domestic decisions as well as foreign policy decisions.
In past westphalian order, Nation states forms the foundation of model of sovereignty. This conception however with developing modes of decision making and interference faces certain challenges to both monistic (John Austin) and pluralistic model.
Firstly, globalisation with emerged with neo-liberal paradigm of market supremacy has impacted the role of decision making. The main tool of it is like MNC's, NGO constrains decision making power. For example, Sovereign's of Asia not being able to localize data from Big techs like google, facebook.
Secondly, the universal Actor model (Morton Kaplan), restricts how nations deal with internal crisis. Mainly instruments like International court of justice, UNHRC and moreover UNAC governs the decision of status.
Thirdly, emergence of technology has made national Sovereign vulnerable. Jamie Bartlett in Book 'people v/s tech' highlight how transfer of decision making from Authorities to technology has reduced the control of them. Even scholars like H.V Pant calls today's era' as 'Technocratic democracies'.
Fourthly, models of Non-State Actors emerging as new force contains the power of even replacing the State Actors. It's visible in terrorist organizations like ISIL (Islamic State of Lebanon and Syria) and Taliban gaining control over Afghanistan.
And lastly, Pandemic like COVID has showcased how the boundaries in modern days have became irrelevant. Scholars like Marshall McLuhan / Susan Strange highlights that world has opened up and surely limited power of Nation state has hardly any relevance.
Yet despite of challenges, assertion of sovereignty too holds power. Robert gilpin highlights that Nation States decision in cutting off from the world (New washington consensus through friendshoring) holds a lot of power.
Barry Buzan from copenhagen school highlights that power of security providance gives power to States which no one can replace. China's model of Beijing led capitalism holds a case.
A middle path in between both views has been showcased by scholars like David held. He rightly highlights the transformation occuring. It is a constant game of never-ending power tussle between factors and Sovereignty.