Comment on the following in about 150 words each: (b) Criticism of Multicultural Perspective on Rights
Arpit Kumar, AIR 421, 2024
Will Kymlicka in 'A liberal theory of minority rights' provides for multicultural rights. It mean moving away from universal notion of rights towards special rights of self-governance, cultural rights etc to minorities.
However, not free from criticism, it has faced backlash. Amartya Sen in 'Argumentative Indian' highlights that multiculturalism can lead to ghettoization of society. It will turn into social divisions based on caste, culture, race which will be evident in society.
Similarly, Scholars of feminist school like Susan moller Okin finds that every culture inherently has some biases towards patriarchy. Giving religious customs/culture would further empower the Subjugation of women.
Marcuse, another proponent like Chandra Kukathas highlights that there can be 'minority within minorities'. Multiculturalism cannot provide a solution to it. For instance, Rohingya muslims in muslim community.
However, Multiculturalism entails it's benefits in providing representation, right to voice, and phenomena of non-assimilation best Salad Bowl approach. Bhiku Parekh in 'Rethinking multiculturalism' provides for multicultural rights to even refugees and migrants.
In Indian context we see Fundamental rights of Article 29-30 for minorities. Similarly, Ganga-Jamuna tehzeeb, Black rights in America form a strong case favouring multiculturalism.