Comment on the following in about 150 words each: (a) Negative and Positive Concepts of Liberty
Arpit Kumar, AIR 421, 2024
Liberty form the core central theme of liberalism. It deals with individuality and provides protection and emancipation to an individual or group in social contract of liberalism.
There emerge two conception of Liberty as meta-narrative. Negative liberty majorly constrains the interference of State in individuals life. On extension, it also applies to market being operating freely.
However, positive liberty which emerge from works of T.H green forms foundation of welfare state. It aims at empowering citizen and state interference for providing equity based authoritative allocation of social goods.
Negative liberty mainly comes up with idea of John Locke. It inspires a night-watchman State just to protect life, liberty and property.
In modern days, Isaiah Berlin outlines important of negative liberty in '4 essays on liberty' and favours toleration.
Similarly, proponents of positive liberty also John Maynard Keynes, harold laski and T.H green. It summarizes state's action through pro poor programmes (PM-KVY) etc for overall development.
In modern days, emergence of constitutionalism provides for negative liberty. However, emergence from Rawlsian 'theory of Justice' we see focus on affirmative Action. (Art 14)
Some new models of liberty are Quinton Skinner's 'liberty as non-dominance' and living under one's own made rules.