Topper Copies

How far does functionalism explain the rise of the European Union, and what challenges does the EU face today?

Animesh Mishra, AIR 428, 2025

European union is a politico-economic union consisting of 29 nations. It was formed under Treaty of Mastricht (1993).

The notion of EU is based on bringing the conflict prone relation of the European nations to relations of cooperation. This idea was based on Kantian notion of perpetual peace by republicanism and was operationalised by help of statesmen like Robert Schuman & Jean Monnet.

The EU as an example of fundimentalism is due to its ability to eschew from the realist assumption of balance of power needed for peace.

Instead, it found on mutual cooperation, functional overlap and common interest as motivating factor.

Further, the EU emerging from European Coal and Steel Community (ECSC) used 'compartmentalisation' of issues into low politics and high politics. It promoted trade among nations to create functional overlaps.

The role of incrementalism as promoted by Fabians too, is seen in the evolution of ECSC to EU over 50 yrs. The EU was able to create trade and commerce as common sense preventing any conflict to be resolved by war.

John McCormick in 'Europeanism' also point to how the economic interdependence led to normative convergence over market economy & human rights eventually. Hence, functional integration intensified making war based on bilateral model irrelevant.

However, the application of functionalism to explain EU's rise would not entirely be complete: 1. Democratic peace theory enabled democracy to promote culture of dialogue and resolving dispute by diplomacy. 2. Economic Interdependence created by supply chain networks prevented war. 3. Sociological Liberalism led to formation of security community with communication approach.

Challenges Faced by EU: 1. Europophillic (France, Germany) vs. Europhobic (Hungary, Poland) pulls in the group. 2. Consolidation post-Brexit remains challenge. 3. EU's complex interdependence with China prevents strategic de-coupling. 4. USA's protectionist policies like Inflation Reduction Act, CHIPS Act is reducing attractiveness of EU. 5. Regulatory state where Ease of Doing Business is reducing ex: GDPR-based regulations. 6. Russia threatening the energy security & security architecture of EU. 7. Limited outreach with rising powers ex: India-EU BTIA stalled.

Hence, EU needs statesmanship which could ensure consolidation and promote EU's strategic autonomy.