Distinguish between old and new social movements.
Animesh Mishra, AIR 428, 2025
Social movements as defined by Charles Tilly is a series of contentious campaigns leading to collective claims by a form of radical democracy.
The old social movement in general focuses on livelihood issues of people. It is a movement for effective redistribution justice. Whereas, the new social movement is about post-material issue of cultural and social hegemony to be challenged.
The old social movement was led by lower-middle class whereas, new social movement includes upper-middle class and epistemic communities.
The old social movement dealt with trade unionism, wage hike protest, farm protest etc. whereas, new social movement was about gender justice, racial justice, peace movement.
Old social movement uses land, street politics, violence too. However, new social movement is silent revolution using cinema, art, music, campaign, conference to raise the consciousness.
In the context of west Europe (developed, industrialised region) we find increase of old social movement due to the rolling back of state, leading to vulnerability ex: pension protest in france, yellow vest protest.
It is also aimed to sensitise the state over livelihood concerns of vulnerable owing to climate transition imperative ex: farmer's tractor movement.
The inability of the state to provide justice to marginalised minorities is the reason for rise of new social movement ex: police brutality by french police towards black boy (2022).
It aims to develop collective solidarity over issues of violence, genocide & ex. Pro-Palestine protest in Germany.
The #metoo movement aimed to challenge the implicit hegemony of patriarchy in the society.
Hence, social movement enables widening civic culture & non-political impulse.