Topper Copies

Have multilateral institutions been successful in ensuring cooperation and peace among sovereign states?

Animesh Mishra, AIR 428, 2025

Multilateral institutions are designed with intent of bringing sovereign actors on a common platform for cooperation & dialogue. It intends to convert relations into 'we'.

Based on the philosophy of idealism and Woodrow Wilson's 14 point speech, the aim of these liberal institutions was to harness enlightened self interest of states to create a rules-based order.

However, it has not been successful in achieving it. It is due to the realist concerns of national interest and interest of survival that motivates state actions, ex: Russia's 'Special Military Operation' due to existential threat of NATO expansion.

Nations are also engaged in "quasi-negotiations" (Joseph Nye), which prevents utility of platforms ex: USA blocking the resolution on ceasefire of Gaza @ UNSC.

The institutional design's lack of enforceability due to no "global leviathan" or policeman also reduces effectiveness in conflict ex: incursion by China on EEZ of South China nations violating UNCLOS.

The issue of power rise of non-state actor due to the current mixed actor model implies that state-led institutions have limited utility ex: violence by ISIS, Hamas etc.

The pariah states like North Korea, who lie outside the fold of multilateral system, also de-stabilise the international system ex: use of ballistic missile to threaten Japan/South Korea.

The economic conflict due to dominance of $ and its unilateral sanctions diplomacy has also created dwindled role of rules-based organisation like WTO, ex: USA sanctioned Venezuela, Cuba etc.

However, the multilateral institutions were important in deployment of UNPKF in Congo, Sudan for peace. The role of 'Responsibility to Protect' also gives opportunity to intervene in states for human rights.

The role of ASEAN's quiet pragmatic diplomacy, Myanmar's 5-point consensus or African union's solution to Ethiopian-Tigray conflict, show the utility.

Thus, we need reformed, democratic multilateralism that ensures peace on enduring basis.