Topper Copies

b) Discuss the bases of India's claim to the permanent seat in the UN Security Council. How far does the goal of permanent seat seem achievable? (15 Marks)

Priyasha Verma, AIR 324, 2025

UNSC is one of the principal agencies of the UN and aims at international peace and security. However, countries like India criticize it for being unrepresentative of contemporary geopolitical realities.

The body has only 5 permanent members known as the P5 and remaining 15 Non Permanent Members. According to Rakesh Sood, it represents status-quo of a bygone era and not the present reality. India claims to get a permanent seat in UNSC.

Bases of India's claim India is the second largest troop contributor to UN Peace Keeping forces which is the biggest basis to claim permanent seat. It has been a responsible power throughout history and has contributed in resolving conflicts like Korea War, Gaza strip conflict, recent South Sudan conflict etc.

India is the fastest growing economy as per IMF and has the 5th largest GDP in the world. Rising economic status requires say in global decision.

Also, it has always complied by international law and respected conventions. It has made changes in domestic laws to comply by global standards. eg. NDPS law.

Further, India now has the largest population and deserves representation as the leading power of Asia.

However, the goal of permanent seat in UNSC is not so easily achievable because of opposition of China which uses its Veto Power and China backed groupings like Coffee Club.

Though, countries like France support India's claims, China would always block it to maintain its hegemony in the global institution.

Hence, as C Raja Mohan says, India must continue to work for rules based international order and simultaneously be vocal for reforms but not go behind super stardom.

According to Tarasita Schaffer, India has emerged as having a multilateral identity and thus its claims must be accepted at the global high table.