Critically examine the Democratic Peace Theory.
Animesh Mishra, AIR 428, 2025
Democratic Peace Theory is given by [Michael Doyle] in 'Ways of Peace and War' where he mentions that the international system proliferation of democracy prevents wars/conflict.
The criticism of the theory includes: 1. Does not fulfil [Popperian] falsification ex: India-Pakistan; Armenia Azerbaijan conflict show that not scientific theory. 2. Used as a tool for justifying military interventions ex: Iraq invasion to form democracy. 3. Promotes western values as universal [Eurocentric]; hence based on western experience ex: ASEAN ensured peace too. 4. Realists like Prof. Morgenthau argue that it is balance of power that ensures peace not democracy. 5. Liberal institutionalists argue that only when institutions are formed only then even undemocratic nations cooperate. 6. English school of Hedley Bull point that reason in states of mutual benefit & cooperation prevents war.
However, if we look at the theoretical justification like Kant's idea of perpetual peace which was implemented in European Union it shows that democracy promotes peace. There is also a culture of toleration & dialogue that develops.
Hence, the theory has relevance in providing normative impetus of democratisation of nations as a tool for enduring peace.