Topper Copies

तमिलनाडु राज्य बनाम तमिलनाडु के राज्यपाल में आए ऐतिहासिक निर्णय ने एक बार फिर भारत की संघीय संरचना, राज्यपाल की विवेकाधीन शक्तियों की सीमाएँ और संविधान के तहत न्यायिक पुनरावलोकन की सीमा जैसे मूल प्रश्नों को उजागर किया। टिप्पणी कीजिए। / The landmark verdict in State of Tamil Nadu vs Governor of Tamil Nadu (2025) once again laid bare the fundamental questions about India's federal structures, the limits of gubernatorial discretion, and the scope of the power of judicial review under the Constitution. Comment.

Animesh Jain, AIR 63, 2025

SC in state of T.N v/s Governor of T.N put up a timeline for both Governor and President to approve State's laws. It thus laid bare a lot of debates on India's constitutional scheme.

India has been described as quasi federal (K.C Wheare). Centre through mechanisms like Governor's office, President's rule (356), laws on State list (Art 249) etc enjoying preponderant power over states. However S.C through repeated pronouncements has strengthened federalism. In S.R Bommai, it held federalism as part of Basic structure. In Nabam Rebia, it ruled federal structure can't be violated by executive.

Similarly, gubernatorial discretion has been hotly debated. In Constitution, governor has both constitutional discretion (Art 163) and situational discretion. The situational discretion is more problematic. For eg, recommending President's rule, reserving Bill for President's assent etc. S.C in Samsher Singh, Hargovind Pant v/s Raghukul Tilak etc has highlighted that Governor has to exercise his discretion based on aid & advice of CoM.

However, gray areas still persist. For example, in Art 200 there is no timeline for Governor to reject a approve bill.

Judicial review is another area of contestation. S.C has ruled that it is part of basic structure in Minerva Mills. However, it has been criticised for compromising parliamentary sovereignty and assuming Judiciary supremacy (eg NJAC case). Whether Judiciary can direct President to adhere to timeline has further ignited the debate.

As Indian constitutionalism continues to evolve, these debate will continue to surface as part of churning process. mature ideas grounded in constitutional morality are needed to solve these issues.