स्वतंत्रता आंदोलन के दौरान 1935 का भारत शासन अधिनियम गुलामी का चार्टर कहा गया था, लेकिन आज भारतीय संविधान का एक-तिहाई हिस्सा उसी से लिया गया है। इस विरोधाभास के संभावित कारणों को स्पष्ट कीजिए। / While during the freedom movement, the Government of India Act 1935 had been reviled as a 'charter of slavery', now more than a third of the Constitution is borrowed from that hated law. What could have been the probable determining factors behind this paradox? Explain.
Animesh Jain, AIR 63, 2025
GoI Act 1935 was rolled out at a time when Indian freedom movement was entering its decisive phase. It was primarily aimed at curtailing civil liberties and increase executive power to check repeat of civil disobedience like movement.
It was criticised by Pt Nehru as a 'charter of slavery' because:
1. It increased the power of Viceroy - act without Council of minister advice, issue ordinances etc 2. Gave emergency powers to executive to check internal unrest by curtailing civil liberties. 3. More powers to union vis a vis provinces like - taxation, irrigation, local government, etc
Despite this, more then third of constitution was borrowed from it. This was criticised by K Hanumanthiya in constituent assembly as:
'we wanted music of sitar but got music of english band'
Despite these criticism, we borrowed the constitution from 1935 Act because:
1. We borrowed only the administrative structure because of familiarity as Congress ministries had worked under Govt Act 1935 form 1935-37. provisions like bicameralism, dyarchy etc were taken to administrative frame only 2. Preference for a strong state to deal with fissiparous tendencies post independence. Thus, provisions like emergency, ordinance making powers, president's rule etc were retained. 3. Dominance of anglicised lawyers in constituent assembly. They were heavily influenced by British state structure and retained its elements.
India's constitution need to be seen in continuum from Regulatory Act 1773. It gradually evolved to needs people's aspirations. However it could
In way it call constitution as 'Carbon copy of 1935' Act.
Marked differences with G.I Act 1935 were:
1. Made India a democratic republic from a colonised state. 2. Recognised Indians as citizens with rights rather then subjects. 3. Ensured checks and balances through empowered parliament and judiciary 4. based on equality where every person was given equal rights (u 326) whereas in G.I Act 1935 franchise was limited.
Thus Indian constitution marks continuity in form but break in essence from G.I Act 1935.