भारत में लोकतंत्र के लिए CEC की महत्वपूर्ण भूमिका के बावजूद, सुप्रीम कोर्ट ने अनुप बरनवाल बनाम भारत संघ (2023) के निर्णय में यह स्पष्ट किया कि सरकारें पारदर्शी नियुक्ति प्रक्रिया को संस्थागत नहीं कर पाई। इस संदर्भ में CEC और अन्य ECs की नियुक्ति, सेवा शर्तों एवं कार्यकाल संबंधी 2023 अधिनियम में किए गए परिवर्तनों का आलोचनात्मक मूल्यांकन कीजिए। / Despite the CEC's vital role in Indian democracy, the Supreme Court in Anoop Baranwal vs UOI (2023) highlighted that successive governments haven't institutionalised a transparent appointment process. Critically evaluate the changes made by the CEC & ECs (Appointment, Conditions of Service & Term of Office) Act 2023 towards realising S.C. guidelines.
Animesh Jain, AIR 63, 2025
S.C has held that free and fair elections are part of Basic Structure (Indira Gandhi vs Raj Narain). An independent E.C is sine que non for free and fair elections.
As per Constitution (Art 324-329), Election Commissioners are appointed by President on advice of Cabinet. This gives sole power of appointment in hand of Centre raising possibility of biased appointments.
To correct this, S.C in Anoop Baranwal case ruled 3 member selection committee comprising CJI, LoP and PM to choose Election Commissioners.
This arrangement was [?] to last pending a law by parliament.
Parliament came with ECI & EC Act, 2023 to revised S.C guidelines. Its provisions include:
1. 3 Member selection committee comprising PM, LoP, Cabinet Minister appointed by PM. 2. A search Committee headed by law minister to recommend 5 names to selection committee to choose from. 3. selection criteria for EC - person of integrity, experience in conduct of elections. 4. Bars reappointment / further appointment in GoI.
This mechanism has been criticised by Faizan Mustaffa for compromising independence of selection committee since now executive has 2-1 majority and can appoint partisan E.C.
However, this mechanism is sound as per ex. CEC SY Qureshi. He argues that S.C judges don't have expertise to assess suitability of an IAS officer for CEC post. Also in no major country judiciary plays a role in E.C appointments.
To make the process more robust SY Qureshi recommends transparent process through laying down credentials of candidates in public domain. This will go a long way in boosting people's faith on the electoral process.