भारत का सर्वोच्च न्यायालय, जो 75 वर्ष पूर्व संवैधानिक परियोजना का एक केंद्रीय भाग बना, क्या वह संविधान निर्माताओं की न्याय संबंधी अपेक्षाओं पर खरा उतर सका है? अपने तर्क प्रस्तुत कीजिए तथा तथ्यों से पुष्ट कीजिए। / The Supreme Court of India was established more than 75 years ago as a core part of India's constitutional project. Do you think the court has been able to live up to the ideals of justice imagined by the framers of the Constitution? Give arguments in favour of your points, and substantiate them with empirical facts.
Animesh Jain, AIR 63, 2025
Constitution established S.C under Art 124 as an institution of ensuring Checks and balance and ensure justice for the people. The record of S.C in realising this has been a mixed one.
S.C has helped realise ideals of justice as evident in:
1. Expanding the scope of Art 21 through successive judgements like Olga Tellis (Right to livelihood), K.S Puttaswamy (Right to privacy). This has helped transform 'right to life' to 'right to dignified life'. 2. Protecting fundamental rights against executive excesses - S.C safeguarded individual liberty as evident in Maneka Gandhi case where it upheld 'due process of law' in Art 21. Similarly in Anuradha Bhasin case, it used right to access to internet in Art 21 & 19 thereby restraining executive 3. Providing justice to vulnerable sections - In NALSA and Navtej Singh Johar, S.C recognised LGBTQ rights. In Sabarimala case and Shayara Bano case, it struck down discriminatory religious practices like temple entry ban & triple talaq respectively 4. V.R Krishna Iyer came up with PIL & epistolary jurisprudence making justice accessible to people
However, in many cases, S.C has been found wanting also in redressing justice:
1. Failure during Emergency - S.C refused when asked to bend. It upheld suspension of Fundamental rights. 2. High pendency of cases - leads to denial of justice. It's taking role of PILs has further stretched it from its core areas. 3. Allegations of corruption and bench fixing as evident in four judges press conference. It shook faith on impartial nature of judiciary.
Despite other challenges, it can be denied that India might have been a failed state without judiciary's active intervention (Zia Mody).