Topper Copies

"भारतीय राज्य ने हमेशा गहरे सामाजिक-आर्थिक परिवर्तन की आकांक्षाओं और ऊर्जा को कृत्रिम सहमति और समन्वयी राजनीति के माध्यम से सीमित करने का प्रयास किया है।" — फ्रांसिन फ्रेंकल। आलोचनात्मक परीक्षण कीजिए। / "The Indian state has always tried to delimit the aspirations of and energy for radical socio-economic changes through a fabricated consensus and accommodative politics." — Francine Frankel. Critically examine.

Animesh Jain, AIR 63, 2025

The Indian State performs the delicate balancing act among different groups and their aspirations. This was visible after independence when violent insurrection broke out in form of Naxalism seeking radical change of agrarian relations through violence. Indian state responded with accommodation through land reforms and rehabilitation policies for ex-militants. It also tried to fabricate consensus against Naxalism as 'anti-national' rather than 'pro-poor' movement. It used its ideological state apparatus like Media, education etc to ideologically defeat Naxalism.

Similarly, the demand of Dalits and OBC for greater representation against Brahmin hegemony was sought to be delimited. State used accommodative policies of Mandal Report and extending 27% reservation to OBCs. It also tried to fabricate consensus for '50% reservation ceiling'. This consensus held till 2024. However, again demands for socio-economic justice made Indian state to agree for caste census (accomodative policy).

Thus, it looks it state acted to delimit aspirations and energy for change. However, this perspective assume state is an agency of dominant class/caste trying to slow down the march of change. However, this isn't true. Representative democracy has ensured that state represent and give voice to different aspirations. Thus as different groups gained their share in state's power, they ensured realisation of their aspirations through state apparatus.

Thus, this consociational model (Arendt Lijphart) of Indian democracy has ensured realisation of different aspirations and helped ensure social justice and good governance