Topper Copies

क्या आप इस मत से सहमत हैं कि जब तक न्यायालयों की सार्थक भूमिका बनी नहीं रहती, तब तक नौकरशाही और कॉर्पोरेट जगत पर्यावरण की रक्षा हेतु आगे नहीं आएंगे? भारत में पर्यावरण आंदोलन में सर्वोच्च न्यायालय की भूमिका का आलोचनात्मक मूल्यांकन कीजिए। / Do you agree with the view that unless the salutary role of the courts is in place, there is no guarantee that bureaucracy and corporations would rise to the occasion to protect the environment? Critically evaluate the role of the Supreme Court in the environmental movement in India.

Animesh Jain, AIR 63, 2025

"polluted rivers, polluted air, destroyed forests, disappearing fauna is what we have after 70 year of independence" - environmentalist P.C Guha

Environment protection has been treated as a secondary concern after independence when uplifting people from poverty was the biggest concern. In words of PM Indira Gandhi, 'poverty is the biggest polluter'. Thus, India's bureaucratic state treated environmental movements with suspicion. In 1970s, Sunderlal Bahuguna was seen as a CIA Agent. Thus Environment Movement was interloper. Bureaucracy while implementing Green Revolution for food sufficiency neglected its disastrous impact on environment. (Vandana Shiva, 'Violence of green Revolution')

same was the case with corporations, with profit as primary motive, it went for rampant exploitation of resources. It led to disastrous impact on people in terms of displacement, loss of livelihood etc. For example, Vedanta mining in Jharkhand led to spread of radioactive waste spoiling environment and harming people.

In this dual assault on environment by corporate-bureaucratic nexus, S.C has stepped in and evolved environmental jurisprudence in India (Lawanya Pajameni). This is reflected in M.C Mehta judgments on ganga pollution when it directed closure of tanneries near river. Similarly in Goa Foundation case, it directed banning of mining in western ghats harming ecosystem.

In recent times, S.C has also started recognising natural entities as 'legal persons'. It gave status of legal entity to ganga river in Mohammed Salim vs state of uttrakhand. S.C has also expanded the scope of Art 21 by incorporating right to be free from adverse impact of climate change in M.K Ranjitsingh Case (2024).

However, this activist role of S.C has come under criticism for violating separation of power. S.C is entering into policy domain, a role it is not equipped in, and neglecting its core tasks. This was visible in Delhi cracker ban case.

Secondly, S.C activism may create challenge for development of infrastructure. This was visible in delayment of Chenab Dam project due to S.C hearing.

Thus, S.C role though welcome is not a panacea. It requires cooperation among state, bureaucracy, corporation and people to ensure sustainable development.