Topper Copies

संवैधानिक पाठ में लिंग की अवधारणा तथा विधायी डिजाइन और न्यायिक हस्तक्षेपों द्वारा उसकी पुनः व्याख्या। / Conceptualisation of Gender in constitutional text and re-articulation by legislative design and judicial interventions.

Animesh Jain, AIR 63, 2025

Gender in the constitution is often linked with biological Sex i.e men and women. This narrow interpretation is a reflection of societal understanding of gender in mid 20th century.

Constitution prohibit discrimination only on grounds of religion, race, sex, place of birth in Art 14,15. Not on gender. Similarly Art 15(3) extended affirmative action to women and children again a narrow interpretation.

Art 38(b) asks for equal pay for equal work for men & women. Art 51A in fundamental duty ask for respect for women. Art 43 provides for maternity relief for women. Thus textual understanding of gender is narrow.

This is re-articulated by legislative design. In Transgender persons (protection of rights) Act, provides for dignity & rights for transgender, gay, lesbian, inter-sex etc thus giving comprehensive interpretation. Similarly PoSH Act and POCSO Act are expansive in nature focussing on wide meaning of gender

Judiciary too through progressive judgments has recognised wide interpretation of gender. In NALSA v/s U.o.I, it recognised third gender. In Navtej Singh Johar, it protected transgender relations. However in Supriyo v/s U.o.I it failed in extending same-sex Marriage right to 12 LGBTQ.