Topper Copies

भारत में लोकतांत्रिक शासन के लिए महत्वपूर्ण संवैधानिक संस्थाओं में से एक के रूप में नियंत्रक एवं महालेखा परीक्षक (CAG) की भूमिका। / Role of CAG as one of the constitutional agencies critical to democratic governance in India.

Animesh Jain, AIR 63, 2025

CAG is often called fifth pillar of Indian democracy (Vinod Rai). His constitutional mandate is given in Art 148-151 and CAG Act 1971 lays down his duties.

CAG performs the function of ensuring financial accountability of executive to legislature. This is ensured through various audits:

1. Audit of Consolidated fund, Contingency fund, public account of India. 2. Audit receipt, expenditure of Centre, states, profit & loss accounts of PSU. 3. Doing propriety audit to ensure efficiency in public expenditure.

Through other methods, CAG has highlighted prominent scams like 2G, coalgate, Bofors, Adarsh society scam etc. In Yamuna Expressway case, it did propriety audit to show wastage of public resources. Thus he ensures transparency & accountability in governance,

However, his role is under challenge due to:

1. political nature of appointment - solely appointed by executive leads to biased appointments (K Joseph). 2. Exclusion of PPP projects and PRI from audit of CAG. 3. He is also criticised for hindsight bias leading to over-critical reports causing policy paralysis.

Nonetheless, CAG office remains critical and must be strengthened through reforms like Collegium for appointment, decentralisation of functions to state units etc